We're going to try something new – a
Synchroblog. One topic, three blog sites and 3 independent bloggers. All with our own take (Although I feel somewhat out of my league with the writing and blogging talents of these two captivating women.) Jewels from According To Jewels, Lydia from On The Other Hand, and of course, myself of The Woven. Let's see where we end
up!
~~ ~~ ~~
Why
Don't Men and Women Share Public Washrooms?
This topic isn't new to the blogsphere.
I began by surfing around the internet trying to get a general feel
of what people thought. The majority of responses fell within 3
groupings: 1) Safety, 2) Privacy, and 3) Culture (as in, it just is
culture. It's what we know. It's what we've been taught and
conditioned to). And there is an abundance of humour to be found
here. I also discovered that, apparently, in Japan men and women
share the same public latrine. Which got me thinking whether the
first 2 concerns (Safety and Privacy) were really just projections
that might fall under Culture.
And there was also a 4th
group, but far from a majority. Some believe we have men and women
public W.C.'s because of gender-policing. That caught my attention,
because for our freedom-based Western values, it sounded a little bit
too Orwellian; Totalitarian; 1984-ish (the novel, not the year. I
love the '80's).
Is there really
a danger of sexual assault or harassment – even being given 'the
look', the once-over, being uninvitedly checked-out, if we were to
introduce unisex public washrooms?
If we can find
examples where mixed public bathrooms are the commonplace and without
an increase of cases of sexual assault or harassment (which we have
in Japan) then this reasoning becomes more of a cultural projection
of fear. (Unless the Japanese are more in control of their 'animal
longings' than we are).
Fact
is, we are commonly seeing more Family Friendly washrooms and even
change rooms. Do we
really believe we are all driven by lust and violence?
In our
more modern times, there is a significant higher level or awareness
and tolerance of gay and lesbian members of society. If gender-based
washrooms are based upon safety (from the threat of sexual assault), then with the
advent of this relatively new (in historic terms) element we should
see this manifest, which I don't believe we do. That could stem over
into privacy issues as well. Would I be comfortable using a urinal
beside a man I know to
be gay? I am not homophobic, but no, I wouldn't.
Privacy? Well,
here's my thoughts on privacy. Stalls are private. Some washrooms are
single-occupant rooms with proper doors and deadbolt locks. But most
importantly, the entire concept of Privacy in a public
environment is somewhat of an oxymoron, isn't it?
One blogger posted
their concern for poor little Sally walking into a unisex
bathroom and seeing Uncle Joe's junk at the urinal. As far as
urinals go, I should think the urinal evolved alongside the
gender-segregated system. (I know many men who do not like urinals
for lack-of-privacy issues).
The fourth option,
that I suspected but rarely heard mention, was gender-policing (...
I'm afraid this is where it gets heavy...)
~~ ~~ ~~
We
Westerners seem to demonstrate a strong habit for gender policing to
enforce the binary of “man” and “women”; boys and girls.
There's several issues worth establishing here. Although
biologically, gender is simple, we know that culturally and
sociologically, gender is quite complex. The simple point of view of,
Take off your pants; you're either a guy or a girl,
is a little bit too shallow. If that were the case, then we would
wear clothing purely for practical purposes. We would not have
gender-specific articles of clothing nor would we have
gender-specific styles
(Woman's ski-jacket vs. Men's ski-jacket). This issue greatly
transcends public washrooms. Gender is much more than biological or
sexual orientation. (Actually, I might argue that Sex and Gender are
two different things altogether).
I
can't help but wonder if our Western perspectives have it all wrong.
If we look at the hijras
of India, Bangladesh and Pakistan, the Fa'afatine
of Polynesia, the Two-Spirited
people of Native Americans and Canadian First Nation's people, we see
old and ancient people
who have long since recognized this aspect within humanity. This is
not a new or modern idea of tolerance.
In our
Western culture, homosexuality was officially considered a mental
illness (insanity) until 1972!
Let alone any idea of an “other” or 3rd
gender.
"So why don't we have them within
our culture or communities
then?"
some may ask; the assumption being, if we don't have them, then they
cannot be a regular part of humanity – that they are a product of a
tolerant culture that allows them.
It is difficult if not impossible to deny their existence within the
human condition and experience. Maybe they are an exception, a sort
of one-off mutation? A perversion or deviant (from a
biological/psychological point of view) of some sort; that they are
not a regular or healthy minority but an aberration?
In
2005, Indian Passport forms were updated with three
gender
options. The Hijra
of India are probably the most well known third sex type in the
modern world. The Humsafar Trust – a Mumbai-based community Health
Organization – estimates that there are between 5 and 6 million
hijras in India. That's a pretty big number (Even as a percentage that's
still around 0.5%. That's the same as the Black Hispanic population
within the USA).
My point simply is, maybe they are a natural aspect of humanity. One
in which our Western world-view has attempted to stifle, repress, or
snuff-out. Maybe to the determent of our entire society. Is our society guilty of behaviour manipulation?
Western
medicine with its symptom-treatment “take-a-pill” philosophy.
Fast food, Instant information, instant gratification. Materialism and
consumerism run amok. Online social networks at the absolute decay of
real
relationships.
Gender-policing.
The more and more I learn and see of other, non-Western world-views,
the more and more I am coming to believe we got it wrong. We got it
so wrong.
~~ ~~ ~~
Okay, okay.
A bit too heavy.
Let's bring this back down to a more mundane reality.
A few of these
facts I knew of. Many were eye opening.
The world as I
know it is not the reality of what the world is.
My world's not real. I think it's healthy to keep that in mind.
Okay, okay. Even lighter still.
In my journey through the googleverse in search for ideas and pic's for this post, I couldn't believe the urinals that are out there! From the fun to the profane, they'll make you laugh and they'll offend you. (I thought to myself, Holy Crap! Do I live in a bubble?). Here are some that - one way or another - caught my attention.
~~ ~~ ~~
Okay, okay. Even lighter still.
In my journey through the googleverse in search for ideas and pic's for this post, I couldn't believe the urinals that are out there! From the fun to the profane, they'll make you laugh and they'll offend you. (I thought to myself, Holy Crap! Do I live in a bubble?). Here are some that - one way or another - caught my attention.